Facebook changed the setting for privacy, thats not an option now. Any other suggestions?
First, go to Settings in the top right corner next to your name. Then click on privacy settings and click on the Search Link. Under that you can edit if you want your profile picture to show up when people search for you. If the "my profile picture" is checked then they can see it. If you uncheck it and save, they will no longer see your default picture on facebook. As far as all your other pictures tagged of you, go to settings and then under privacy click on profile and change all the settings to friends only. If you want to eliminate certain friends from looking at your pics, you can also click on edit custom settings and type in their name specifically. They won't be able to see your pics while the rest of your friends still can. Hope that helps!! =)
If you really want your profile pic to be private then you should just not put one up at all. And possibly you can only share certain info when people first come to your page so then you can put pictures up on your albums if you want to show your friends that it is really you.